Face frame vs frameless: the same cabinet as two cut lists
The same 24 inch base cabinet as a face frame and a frameless cut list, side by side: parts, depth, door sizes and edge banding, all from the rules engine.
A face frame cabinet adds a solid wood frame to the front of the box and hangs overlay or inset doors on it. A frameless cabinet has no frame, so the sides carry the hinges and the doors cover the whole front. For the same 24 inch base the face frame list has 20 parts against 15, and 5 of the face frame parts are solid wood rather than sheet.
The difference runs through the sizes: frameless sides are 24 deep against 23 1/4, and the frameless door is 23 7/8 by 23 3/4 against 22 by 21 1/2.
The 24 inch base in both styles
Both cabinets are 24 wide, 34 1/2 high and 24 deep with a 5 drawer front over a door on the face frame, a 6 drawer front over a door on the frameless, and one shelf. Everything else is at the product default: 23/32 plywood, 1/4 rabbeted back, butt joints. The style-specific defaults are the toe kick (notch for face frame, legs for frameless) and which edges get banded.
| Part | Qty | Length | Width | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Side | 2 | 34 1/2 | 23 1/4 | C-5, C-6 |
| Bottom | 1 | 22 9/16 | 23 | C-8, C-9, C-10 |
| Stretcher | 2 | 22 9/16 | 4 | C-11 |
| Back, 1/4 | 1 | 23 5/16 | 30 | C-12 |
| Shelf | 1 | 22 7/16 | 22 3/4 | C-14 |
| Toe kick board | 1 | 24 | 4 1/2 | C-16 |
| Frame stile | 2 | 1 1/2 | 30 | F-2 |
| Frame rail (top) | 1 | 21 | 1 1/2 | F-3, F-4 |
| Frame rail (middle) | 1 | 21 | 1 1/2 | F-3, F-4 |
| Frame rail (bottom) | 1 | 21 | 1 1/2 | F-3, F-4 |
| Drawer front (drawer 1) | 1 | 22 | 6 | D-4 |
| Drawer side (drawer 1) | 2 | 22 | 4 1/4 | B-4, B-5, B-7 |
| Drawer front/back (drawer 1) | 2 | 19 | 4 1/4 | B-3, B-7 |
| Drawer bottom, 1/4 (drawer 1) | 1 | 19 1/2 | 21 1/2 | B-8 |
| Door (door 2) | 1 | 22 | 21 1/2 | D-1 |
| Part | Qty | Length | Width | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Side | 2 | 30 | 24 | C-5, C-6 |
| Bottom | 1 | 22 9/16 | 23 3/4 | C-8, C-9, C-10 |
| Front stretcher | 1 | 22 9/16 | 4 | C-11 |
| Rear stretcher | 1 | 22 9/16 | 4 | C-11 |
| Back, 1/4 | 1 | 23 5/16 | 30 | C-12 |
| Shelf | 1 | 22 7/16 | 23 1/2 | C-14 |
| Toe kick board | 1 | 24 | 4 1/2 | C-16 |
| Drawer front (drawer 1) | 1 | 23 7/8 | 6 | D-10 |
| Drawer side (drawer 1) | 2 | 22 | 4 23/32 | B-4, B-5, B-7 |
| Drawer front/back (drawer 1) | 2 | 20 9/16 | 4 23/32 | B-3, B-7 |
| Drawer bottom, 1/4 (drawer 1) | 1 | 21 1/16 | 21 1/2 | B-8 |
| Door (door 2) | 1 | 23 7/8 | 23 3/4 | D-10 |
What changes, and why
| Item | Face frame | Frameless | Rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total parts | 20 | 15 | all |
| Sheet parts / solid wood parts | 15 / 5 | 15 / 0 | F-1 to F-4 |
| Side height x depth | 34 1/2 x 23 1/4 | 30 x 24 | C-3, C-5 |
| Bottom length x depth | 22 9/16 x 23 | 22 9/16 x 23 3/4 | C-8, C-9 |
| Toe kick style | notch | legs | C-3, C-16 |
| Top members | Two stretchers | Front and rear stretcher | C-11 |
| Door size | 22 x 21 1/2 | 23 7/8 x 23 3/4 | D-1, D-10 |
| Drawer front | 22 x 6 | 23 7/8 x 6 | D-4, D-10 |
| Banded edges (count) | 9 | 13 | ER-1 |
| Banding, feet before waste | 13.8 | 23.5 | ER-3 |
Depth consequence
On a face frame cabinet the stated depth includes the frame, so the sides are shortened by the frame thickness. On a frameless cabinet the box is the depth.
H_side x D_side = 34 1/2 x 23 1/4 (D_side = D - T_ff = 24 - 3/4 = 23 1/4)
H_side x D_side = 30 x 24 (D_side = D - 0 = 24 = 24)
So the two cabinets sit the same distance out from the wall, but the frameless box is 3/4 deeper inside. The drawer slide is picked from the clear depth (rule B-5), and in this example both cabinets end up with the same slide length because the frame thickness is added back to the face frame depth.
Doors: opening plus overlay, or the front zone
A face frame door is sized from the opening in the frame. For an overlay door the width is the opening plus the overlay on each side (D-1), and the height is the same. A frameless door is sized from the cabinet itself. The front zone is the box width less a reveal at each side (D-8), and a single door fills it (D-10). A pair splits it with a gap (D-11).
Door = (W_op + 2O) x (H_op + 2O) = (21 + 1) x (20 1/2 + 1) = 22 x 21 1/2
Door = W_fz x h = (24 - 1/8) x 23 3/4 = 23 7/8 x 23 3/4
The face frame door is smaller than the cabinet width, because the frame stiles take part of the width. The frameless door is 1/8 narrower than the cabinet, which is the two side reveals. The overlay, inset and reveal settings have their own page: door overlay and reveal explained.
Edge banding differs by style
On a face frame cabinet the frame covers the front edges of the box, so only the shelf front is banded by default. Frameless sides, bottom, front stretcher and shelves have an exposed front edge and are banded there. Doors and drawer fronts are banded on all four edges in both styles. The banding page, edge banding allowance and cut size, shows what that does to cut sizes and footage.
Which list should you build from
The engine does not pick for you. It gives you the list for the style you choose. Face frame work asks for solid wood stock and a jointing method for the frame. Frameless asks for more banding and accurate drilling for hinges and shelf pins. Count of sheets is about the same, as the whole-kitchen runs in how many sheets for a kitchen show, and how the layout is cut is covered in sheet layout and saw kerf.
Common mistakes
- Using frameless door sizes on a face frame cabinet. The door would be 1 7/8 too wide and 2 1/4 too tall for the openings.
- Cutting face frame sides at the full cabinet depth. They should be 23 1/4, and the frame makes up the difference.
- Banding the carcass fronts on a face frame cabinet. The frame covers them. The engine leaves them off by default and you can turn them on per part class.
- Mixing the drawer opening rule. A face frame drawer box is sized from the frame opening and a frameless one from the cabinet interior (B-1).
For the box construction see how to build a base cabinet box, and for the toe kick choices see toe kick styles.
Questions people ask
Does a frameless cabinet need fewer parts than a face frame cabinet?
Yes for the same cabinet, because it has no frame. A frameless cabinet needs no stiles or rails, but it has a rear stretcher and its sides are deeper. The exact counts for a 24 inch base are in the comparison table above.
Why are frameless doors bigger than face frame doors?
A frameless door covers the whole front of the box, less a reveal at each side (rules D-8 to D-10). A face frame door is sized from the opening in the frame plus an overlay (rule D-1), so it is narrower than the cabinet.
Which edges are banded on each style?
By default a face frame cabinet bands only the shelf front, because the frame covers the carcass fronts. A frameless cabinet bands the front edge of the sides, bottom, front stretcher and shelves. Doors and drawer fronts are banded on all four edges in both styles.
Is the depth the same on both styles?
The stated cabinet depth is the same, but on a face frame cabinet it includes the frame, so the sides are shorter by the frame thickness (rule C-5). The frameless sides run the full depth.
Can I change the toe kick style on either cabinet?
Yes. Face frame cabinets start with a notch and frameless cabinets start with levelling legs, but kick style is a setting. The toe kick guide shows the numbers for each option.